Skip to content

Your 5th Night Is on Us

Why rush back to reality? Stay four nights with this offer and get the fifth on us, one more day for white-sand lounging, waterfront dining, and sunset chasing.

Keep the OOO On
Thanksgiving 2026

Menus

Menus

Savor & Celebrate
Enjoy an elegant holiday dinner prepared by our award-winning culinary team of chefs.
Thanksgiving Day Dinner

Serving: 12:00pm – 9:00pm

Reservations Required, please call: 305.292.5394

FIRST COURSE
Butternut Squash and Pumpkin Bisque
16

Roasted Pepitas, Truffle Honey, Crème Fraîche
Benvolio Pinot Grigio 15-

Oven Roasted Beets
17

Goat Cheese and Black Pepper Cream Sauce, Candied Walnuts, Lemon Tossed Arugula
A to Z Wineworks Pinot Noir 16-

Shrimp Cocktail
24

House Cocktail Sauce, Grilled Lemon
La Marca Prosecco 16-

SECOND COURSE
Thanksgiving Dinner
50

Roasted Heritage Turkey, Chicken Apple Sausage Stuffing, Yukon Mashed Potatoes, Sage Turkey Gravy, Mushroom Green Bean Casserole, Tobacco Onions, Thyme and Honey Glazed Heirloom Carrots, Cherry and Cranberry Relish

Chateau Ste Michelle, Dry Riesling 15-

Lobster and Crab Stuffed Red Snapper
50

Tarragon Jasmine Rice, Sautéed Asparagus, Carrot, Hert Coverts

The Prisoner Chardonnay 19-

Roasted Prime Rib
58

12oz, Yukon Mashed Potatoes, Grilled Carrots, Rosemary Jus, Horseradish

Silver Palm, Cabernet Sauvignon 16-

Wild Mushroom Risotto (V)
32

Grilled Asparagus Tips, Roasted Tomato, Roasted Root Vegetable

La Crema Pinot Gris 17-

THIRD COURSE
Homemade Pumpkin Pie
15

Whipped Cream

The Night Ferry
17
Brown Butter Apple Streusel
15

Warm Spices, Vanilla Ice Cream

Nutty Captain
17

Sign up for news & updates from Sunset Key Cottages

Local: 305.292.5300 Res: 855.995.9799
245 Front Street, Key West, FL 33040